WhichPetPlan

Find the plan that pays out for your dog or cat.

Short answer

Healthy Paws is the best pet insurance for most dogs in 2026 (editorial score 9.3/10, no annual payout limit). Lemonade is the top pick for cats in our editorial ranking. Compare current quotes using the same pet and coverage choices; our catalog does not establish which insurer costs least. Pre-existing conditions are excluded by every insurer we review.

Our Advisor asks nine questions to compare policy features that matter for your pet, including waiting periods, exclusions and annual limits. It cannot determine whether an insurer will cover a particular condition; your policy and veterinary records decide that.

8
insurers compared
9
questions in the Advisor
1
live quote partner: Lemonade
Pet Plan Advisor
Question 1 of 9

First things first: what's your pet called?

So the Advisor can stop saying “your pet”.
No email needed
How we rank:26 scored criteria · payout behaviour checked against real claim reports.Read the methodology
The 2026 rankings

Eight plans worth your money

Editorial rankings and policy tradeoffs. Compare current quotes for your pet and coverage choices before deciding.

Our top pick
H
Healthy Paws
Score 9.3 · No annual limit
Unlimited
Most dogs. Unlimited payout and fast reimbursement — but no wellness add-on and premiums climb steeply after age eight.
L
Lemonade
Score 9 · $100k
$100k
Puppies and app-based claims. Claims settle in-app — but not sold in every state and dental is thin.
E
Embrace
Score 8.8 · $2k–unlimited
$2k–unlimited
Owners who rarely claim. Your deductible drops $50 every claim-free year. Accident and illness annual limits run from $2,000 to unlimited.
T
Trupanion
Score 8.6 · No annual limit
Unlimited
Anyone who can't float a big bill. The only insurer that routinely settles at the desk — check its current quote against reimbursement plans.
S
Spot
Score 8.3 · $2.5k–unlimited
$2.5k–unlimited
Custom budgets. More limit and deductible combinations than anyone — which also makes it the easiest plan to accidentally under-buy.
P
Pets Best
Score 8.1 · $5k–unlimited
$5k–unlimited
Fast start. Short 3-day accident wait (waivable with a qualifying vet exam), but cruciate ligament events wait 6 months unless a participating veterinarian certifies the pet.
F
Figo
Score 7.9 · $5k–unlimited
$5k–unlimited
Maximum payback. One of the few offering full reimbursement — and the app is where all service happens.
F
Fetch
Score 7.6 · $15k
$15k
Older dogs. Covers dental disease and behavioural care others exclude — but has a modest annual cap.
Get a quote for your pet and ZIP code, then compare the same deductible, reimbursement rate and annual limit. Want the full ranked rundown with the catch for each? Best pet insurance 2026.

Start with your breed

Breed decides what your dog or cat will probably claim for — and which insurers quietly file it under “hereditary” and say no.

All 16 breeds →

How a claim actually goes

1
You pay the vet in full

Nearly every US insurer reimburses you afterwards, dogs and cats alike. Budget for the entire bill up front — only Trupanion routinely settles at the desk.

2
Your deductible comes off first

Annual on most plans, per-condition on a few. Per-condition looks cheaper and quietly costs more across a long illness.

3
They reimburse your percentage

Usually 70, 80 or 90% of what remains, up to the annual limit. Payout lands in 2 days with the best insurers, six weeks with the worst.

Where claims get denied
·Pre-existing is broader than you think. Symptoms before coverage starts or during a waiting period can make a condition pre-existing, even without a diagnosis. Delaying the vet visit does not change that.
·Check the waiting period for knees and hips. Lemonade currently lists 30 days for orthopedic conditions. Other insurers and state policies differ. Check the terms in your quote before choosing.
·Check coverage for hereditary conditions. Spot includes eligible hereditary conditions. Check each policy for exclusions, waiting periods and limits before comparing.
·Dental coverage depends on the plan. Spot includes eligible dental illnesses in its accident-and-illness plan. Lemonade offers dental add-ons. Compare illness treatment, extractions and routine cleaning separately.

Sources: Lemonade waiting periods, Spot coverage, Lemonade add-ons.

Questions owners actually ask

It depends on whether you could absorb a $7,000 bill tomorrow without it changing your decision about treatment. On averages, most owners pay in slightly more than they claim — that is how insurance works. What you are buying is protection from the tail: the cruciate repair, the cancer course, the swallowed corn cob at 2am. If you have savings deep enough to cover that and the discipline not to spend them, self-insuring is a legitimate choice, so compare that reserve with the policy premium, deductible, exclusions, and annual limit.

The exclusions cheat sheet

A plain-English guide to waiting periods and key exclusions across eight insurers, with links to the full reviews.

Get the sheet plus four follow-up emails over three weeks. Unsubscribe anytime. No insurer gets your address.

Nine questions. Your ranked results.

No email, no phone call, no salesperson. See all eight plans ranked for your pet, with the policy facts behind every position.

Start the Advisor