Lemonade vs Healthy Paws
Healthy Paws is the better choice for most dogs: it is our top-scored plan at 9.3/10, pays out with no annual cap, and has no accident waiting period at all. Lemonade wins on price, with illustrative dog premiums starting around $28/mo versus $44/mo for Healthy Paws, plus a wellness add-on Healthy Paws does not offer. The tradeoffs: Lemonade is not sold in twelve states, has a 6-month cruciate ligament wait, and caps out at $100,000 a year. If you can buy Lemonade in your state and budget is the priority, it is a strong pick. For most owners who want the deepest coverage, Healthy Paws wins this head-to-head.
Side by side
| Lemonade | Healthy Paws | |
|---|---|---|
| Editorial score (dogs) | 9/10 | 9.3/10 |
| Illustrative starting price | dogs from $28/mo, cats from $16/mo | dogs from $44/mo, cats from $24/mo |
| Annual limit | $100k | Unlimited |
| Deductible | Fully customizable, $100 to $750 (up to $1,000 on some policies) | One annual deductible, chosen at enrollment: $100, $250, $500 or $1,000 |
| Reimbursement options | 70%, 80% or 90% | 70%, 80% or 90% |
| Accident wait | 2 days (0 days in AL, AR, CT, DC, GA, IL, IN, IA, MD, MS, NE, NH, NM, OH, SC, TX, UT, WA) | No waiting period |
| Illness wait | 14 days | 15 days |
| Orthopedic / cruciate wait | 30 days for orthopedic conditions generally, 6 months for cruciate ligament events specifically | Hip dysplasia waits 30 or 365 days (depends on state) for pets enrolled at 6 or younger; pets enrolled at 6 or older are not covered for hip dysplasia at all |
| Wellness add-on | Available | Not offered |
| Direct vet pay | No, reimbursement only | No, reimbursement only |
Starting prices are illustrative estimates for a healthy one-year-old animal, not quotes. Your real premium depends on breed, age, ZIP code, deductible and reimbursement rate.
Pre-existing conditions
Lemonade: Not covered, standard exclusion for anything showing signs before enrollment or during the waiting period.
Healthy Paws: Not covered. A condition counts as pre-existing if it showed any sign, even undiagnosed, before your policy started or during the 15-day waiting period. If one knee's cruciate ligament was hurt before enrollment or during the wait, the other knee's cruciate is excluded too.
Choose Lemonade if
Your priority is the monthly price, you live in a state where Lemonade is sold, and your pet is young. Illustrative dog premiums start around $28/mo, claims settle in-app, and you can add wellness, dental illness, behavioral and physical-therapy coverage piece by piece. Just go in knowing the cruciate ligament wait is 6 months and the annual cap, while configurable up to $100,000, is not unlimited.
Choose Healthy Paws if
You want the strongest core coverage and do not care about wellness add-ons. Healthy Paws pays out with no annual limit, has no accident waiting period, and scores highest in our rankings at 9.3/10. The catches: no wellness option at any tier, premiums climb steeply after age eight, and dogs enrolled at 6 or older are not covered for hip dysplasia at all.
Questions
Keep reading
Written by the WhichPetPlan editorial team. We currently earn no commission from any insurer listed, so no comparison here is paid placement. Scores are our own editorial ratings, not an industry standard. See our methodology for how scores are set.