About WhichPetPlan
Who runs WhichPetPlan and how does it make money?
WhichPetPlan is an independent site that compares 8 pet insurers for dogs and cats. The WhichPetPlan editorial team researches and maintains every page. We make money from one paid link: Lemonade may pay us when a reader asks for a quote. The other seven insurers pay us nothing, and no insurer can pay to change a score.
Who we are
WhichPetPlan is an independent comparison site for pet insurance. The WhichPetPlan editorial team researches and maintains the content. We compare 8 insurers: Healthy Paws, Lemonade, Embrace, Trupanion, Spot, Pets Best, Figo, and Fetch.
Dogs and cats get separate rankings. Each insurer has its own review page with its waiting periods, deductible choices, reimbursement rates, payout limits and pre-existing condition rules.
How we make money
Lemonade is the only insurer we have a paid link with. When you tap a Lemonade quote button, Lemonade may pay us a referral fee. The fee does not change the price you pay.
Healthy Paws, Embrace, Trupanion, Spot, Pets Best, Figo, and Fetch pay us nothing. We have no paid link with any of them.
Payment does not set our scores. Our #1 pick for dogs is Healthy Paws, and Healthy Paws pays us nothing. Lemonade, the one insurer that can pay us, is #2 for dogs and #1 for cats.
Lemonade Pet is not available in Alaska, Idaho, Kansas, South Dakota, Vermont, West Virginia, or Wyoming (Lemonade FAQ, checked 2026-11-13). On pages for those states we do not show a Lemonade quote button.
How we score insurers
Each insurer gets an editorial score out of 10. We set it with the WhichPetPlan Policy Checklist, 26 questions about waiting periods, deductibles, limits, pre-existing rules, wellness and more. The scores were last reviewed on 2026-08-17.
The score is our own judgment. It is not an industry rating, and it is not a customer survey. Other review sites often rate the same insurer very differently, so check more than one source before you buy.
How we keep facts current
Coverage facts come from each insurer's own site: its FAQ, sample policy and cost pages. Each of the 8 insurer fact sheets lists its sources, and the insurer list carries a "last verified" date (newest: 2026-08-17). Some facts carry their own check date, such as the list of states where Lemonade is sold (checked 2026-11-13).
Before each build, scripts scan our blog and answer copy for claims we found wrong in the past, such as old Lemonade waiting periods, old price figures and an outdated list of states. The build stops if one comes back.
If a fact cannot be traced to a source, we leave it out instead of guessing. To report an error, send WhichPetPlan a message on Facebook or X.
What we are not
We are not an insurance company or an insurance agency. We do not sell policies. We are not vets, and we do not give veterinary, legal or financial advice.
Prices on this site are examples, not quotes. Your real price, coverage and terms come from the insurer. Read the policy wording before you buy.
Questions
Who runs WhichPetPlan?
The WhichPetPlan editorial team. WhichPetPlan is an independent comparison site that covers 8 pet insurers for dogs and cats.
Does WhichPetPlan get paid by pet insurers?
Only by Lemonade, and only through its quote link. Lemonade may pay a referral fee. The other seven insurers pay us nothing.
Can an insurer pay for a better score?
No. No insurer pays to change a score or a ranking spot. Our #1 dog pick, Healthy Paws, pays us nothing.
Does WhichPetPlan sell pet insurance?
No. We are not an insurer or an insurance agency. You buy the policy from the insurer, and the insurer sets the price and terms.
Where do your coverage facts come from?
From each insurer's own FAQ, sample policy and cost pages, plus named third-party sources. Each review lists the sources it used.